Virginia landlord convicted of racial harassment and fraud against tenants

A Virginia owner was sentenced to 17 years in prison for a series of heinous crimes against his black tenants, including racial harassment and identity theft to fraudulently obtain COVID relief funds. David L. Merryman, 59, owned more than 60 rental properties in Newport News and Hampton, predominantly black areas.

The crimes committed

According to reports from Law and Crime and a Justice Department press release, Merryman’s actions spanned from 2019 to January 2024. He engaged in a fraudulent scheme that involved obtaining rent relief benefits to which he was not entitled, while charged high upfront payments from tenants for properties that were in poor condition.

His properties, located mainly in low-income neighborhoods, were often uninhabitable, with problems such as holes in the ceilings, leaks and rodent infestations. Merryman targeted black families who had limited housing options, exploiting their vulnerability to maximize his profits.

Racial harassment and discrimination

Merryman’s crimes were not limited to financial fraud. He was also accused of racially harassing his tenants, using profanity and making derogatory comments related to slavery. This behavior violated the tenants’ right to live free from racial harassment and threats.

Victims reported suffering not only financial exploitation but also emotional and psychological trauma due to Merryman’s actions. Brian Dugan, special agent in charge of the FBI’s Norfolk field office, noted that Merryman’s victims were often parents struggling to support their families, underscoring the predatory nature of his actions.

Fraudulent COVID aid applications

During the COVID-19 pandemic, Merryman took advantage of the situation by submitting fraudulent applications for rent relief. He used his tenants’ personal information without their consent, forging signatures to secure housing assistance payments from the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). This included making false statements about the condition of his rental properties and failing to disclose other payments he was receiving.

Rae Oliver Davis, the inspector general for HUD, condemned Merryman’s actions, stating“His criminal actions were in repugnant disregard for both the law and the welfare of his low-income tenants.” The ruling serves as a critical reminder of the legal and ethical responsibilities that landlords have towards their tenants, particularly those from marginalized communities.

The case against Merryman underscores the urgent need for accountability in the housing sector, particularly regarding the treatment of black tenants and other vulnerable populations. The 17-year prison sentence not only brings justice to the victims, but also sends a strong message that racial discrimination and fraud will not be tolerated.

As communities continue to navigate the challenges of housing insecurity, it is critical to advocate for fair treatment and respect the rights of all tenants. The actions of individuals like Merryman highlight systemic issues that require continued attention and reform to ensure safe and fair housing for everyone.